DEBORAH M. PRUM

DEBORAH PRUM

Stories, Essays and Reviews

Book Review: THE SENTENCE BY LOUISE ERDRICH

THE SENTENCE
BOOK REVIEW

Many years ago, I lived in Hanover, NH as the same time as Louise Erdrich. We shared the same midwife, a fact I learned from her autobiographical book The Blue Jay’s Dance. I knew about her existence in the community because her early writing was already gaining attention and great acclaim. (She didn’t know about my existence because the only acclaim and attention I’d garnered at the time was for being the shortest Italian-American person in Hanover.)

I’ve just finished reading her most recent book, The Sentence. Prior to this, I’d read Love Medicine, Beet Queenand possibly a story in The New Yorker, but nothing else for decades, which was a mistake on my part, because she is a wonderful writer.

Reminiscent of a zany Elmore Leonard tale, the opening of the book took me by surprise. Three women are involved in the unconventional and illegal transport of a dead body whose name used to be Budgie. Only a woman named Tookie takes the blame. She’s sent off to prison for a good long time during which she is sustained by her love for books.

When Tookie is released, she begins work in a bookstore in Minneapolis, one very much like the one that Louise Erdrich currently owns. In fact, a minor character named Louise runs the fictional bookstore. Erdrich takes the opportunity to include a few funny self-references.

A second surprise for me was that both Tookie and the bookstore are haunted by a ghost named Flora who does not float around and occasionally whisper “Boo.” Instead, Flora is a dynamic force who haunts with such vigor that she causes Tookie to experience an incapacitating breakdown.

            This expansive tale is about identity, passion, betrayal, misunderstandings, spirituality, marriage, Indigenous culture, the treatment of Indigenous people and how a person who’s been beaten down by life can show remarkable resilience. Erdrich gives readers a riveting inside view of multiple levels of trauma experienced by the Minneapolis community during Covid and after the murder of George Floyd. Regarding Covid, I’d forgotten and/or blocked out what daily life felt like back at the height of the pandemic. Regarding the events surrounding George Floyd’s murder, Erdrich gives a gripping depiction of the varied responses among community members. She wraps up the book with a big wallop of narrative tension and a satisfying pay off.

            A wonderful benefit of this novel that Erdrich lists Tookie’s favorite books at the end of the novel. I’ve read enough the books on the list to know that “Tookie’s” taste and mine align, which makes me want to read my way through the rest of the suggestions.

            The book title shows up throughout the novel and has many meanings, including the most obvious, which is Tookie’s unfair prison sentence. However, several times, Erdrich mentions the concept of a sentence of great significance. I don’t want to reveal any plot points here, so I’ll just say that the last line of the book serves as an inspirational sign and wonder, perhaps a message for all of us: “The door is open. Go.”

(Photo by Jen Fariello)
Deborah Prum’s fiction has appeared in The Virginia Quarterly ReviewAcross the MarginStreetlight and other outlets. Her essays air on NPR member stations and have appeared in The Washington PostLadies Home Journal and Southern Living, as well as many other places. Check out her WEBSITE. Check out her DEVELOPMENTAL EDITING SERVICES. Check out her PAINTINGS

2 thoughts on “Book Review: THE SENTENCE BY LOUISE ERDRICH”

  1. Thanks for this review, Deborah. I’ll have to add the book to my reading list. I’ve read a few of Erdrich’s books–got interested after Bill’s cousin’s daughter worked in Louise’s book store. The cousin’s daughter is part Native American and recommended Erdrich’s books. My in-laws lived through COVID in Minneapolis and are still living with the ramifications in the area of George Floyd’s murder. I’m eager to hear another voice bearing witness to that time and place.
    –Laurie

    1. Thank you for your comment, Laurie. I am just seeing it.That’s so cool that you have the connection to Erdrich and the bookstore. I’m sorry I haven’t been able to make it to the music group in a while. I got Covid August 7th and then have gotten hit hard with asthma issues for the past weeks. I’m just coming out of it now, but have low energy. Improv rehearsals have started up again on Tuesday nights (used to be Sunday nights) so it may be a while before I can attend music nights.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *